Showing posts with label PSG. Show all posts
Showing posts with label PSG. Show all posts

Tuesday, 11 September 2012

Have you heard the one about about "Uefa Financial Fair Play"?

Manchester City's Boardroom
after "UFP" was announced.

UEFA has "grabbed" headlines for imposing its "forward thinking" financial fairplay laws into place which is to ensure that clubs play "within their means". Twenty-three clubs have been affected by this first round of audits with their UEFA competition participation prize money being withheld until they can prove their finances are sustainable. Some bigger names DO make this list such as: Atletico Madrid, Malaga, Sporting, Rubin Kazan and Fenerbahce. For a complete list please read the link at the end of the article. 

You'd be forgiven if you have forgotten Mark Viduka's
Champions' League run with Leeds United. Who? Yeah.
As the opening graphic suggests I have a can of sass that I wish to open; however, I will first start by saying that UFF is a step in the right direction. 

One small step, not a giant leap for footy-kind however. Once again, I race ahead of myself. 

Over the years we have seen several big name clubs achieve financial pitfalls because of unsustainable spending (which often leads to book-cooking, auditing, penalties and disaster). The biggest examples that come to mind are Leeds United, Juventus, Portsmouth and Rangers. Leeds United and Rangers are perhaps the most explicit cases where a league contender (and winner) gets audited and tossed down several divisions (from which Leeds has yet to recover, ten years down the road; in 2002 they were in the semi-finals of the Champions' League). These types of financial decisions affect the whole league, the players and - most of all - the hard-working, big-paying fans who support the club and now have to watch the team that had played Valencia in the semis of the CF play (and lose) to fucking Brimbsy. Sustainability is good. Good for the environment, good for finances, good for football. 
500 million spent in four seasons is sustainable?
With no "legacy"-related revenues.
Ok, UEFA.

There is a big "but" in all this UFF talk however. If you look at the remainder of the names of the list you'll see a lot of minnows with irresponsible boardrooms who are just trying to compete in their leagues and make a splash in - at most - the Europa League. With teams afraid of the further steps of the UFF which might be unveiled in future seasons - including stiff financial penalties - smaller teams will be forced to stay small. While this might mean that "domestic" players get more development time, it does mean that a lot of mid-table teams with European aspirations might have to stay dreamers as they watch teams with endless loads of money be declared "sustainable". 

Which brings me to my main point. UFF actually helps the "worst" kind of football teams (in my opinion): the Oil-i-garch owned teams such as Chelsea FC, Manchester City, Shakhtar Donetsk and Paris St. Germain (plus all the other which might spring up as money laundering becomes more challenging under the Putin government). These teams will - in theory - always be sustainable because they almost literally have an endless supply of money (at least until dirty oil and natural gas becomes unfashionable). Now, these teams aren't entirely unaffected: (http://www.bbc.co.uk/sport/0/football/14482429) As this FAQ demonstrates, the books need to be balanced based on revenue generated by ticket-sales, shirt sales, tv deals, etc (which then cannot exceed the players coming in, salaries, etc). 

Ibrahimovich makes more in one month than some of the
clubs he will play against. Sustainable?
HOWEVER, two facts need to be recognized. First and foremost, these laws won't be fully enforced for three years, during which the Oil-i-garchs can spend another half a billion dollars on players (and investments which can generate "legit" income). Secondly, the penalties will be financial in nature and just as the oil companies which finance these clubs don't give a HOOT about their petty fines for destroying the environment, they are not likely to care about a typical UEFA slap-on-the-wrists (Racism fines at EUROS anyone??). Meanwhile, more mid-table, mid-income teams will feel the need to over-spend and cook their books in order to compete with these financially-bottomless juggernauts. 

If UFF is to actually accomplish the grand vision of preventing debt-driven clubs and instill "fairness" into UEFA competitions then it needs to do one of two big gestures: A) they need to actually set transfer and salary limits on teams entering it's big competitions (UCL and Europa League); B) they need to enforce this actively by KICKING OUT teams which step outside these tightly set boundaries; and C) UEFA really needs to establish a set of rules for the purchase and financing of football clubs so Manchester Cities do not keep occurring. 

You'll forgive me if I do not hold my breath. 

The link which inspired this rant: (http://www.bbc.co.uk/sport/0/football/19557934) 

Wednesday, 5 September 2012

Champions' League 2012 / 2013 Pt. I

The beginning of the Champions' League is one of my favorite times of year. Hands down the best football is played in this tournament and every year there are some mouthwatering match-ups between Europe's elite clubs, plus an array of teams pushing to be known as the next season's giant-killer. I get a little sentimental whenever I hear the Champions' League anthem for the first time each season, knowing what lies around the corner: excitement, drama, exaltation, dejection. 

Some groups have more standout sagas than others. Here are my comments on what to look out for along with a few predictions. 

GROUP A (Porto, Dynamo Kyiv, PSG, Dinamo Zagreb)
Ibra: worth the pay stub?

Rest assured the headlines for Group A clashes will be of a financial nature: will PSG's millions be able to buy them advancement into the tournament? With Porto the only clear standout in this group, PSG's advancement would seem all but guaranteed, but after drawing the first of their three games in France's League 1, the PSG experiment seems to be fumbling. PSG will hope that their big summer signings of Ibrahimovic, Thiago Silva and Lavezzi start paying dividends. With a starting lineup that is increasingly looking like a FIFA 2013 fantasy lineup, PSG will be turning heads. PSG reminds me of Man City right after they had a billion dollars thrown at them: huge pay stubs, very little chemistry. Expect some headline making surprises in this group as teams with much more chemistry break down PSG. Although he had a hot-and-cold EURO, Porto's Moutinho managed to stay with his club despite suitors from the EPL and looks like being the potential stand out player in this group if his play-making form continues from the previous season. 

Prediction: I am going to let my pessimism shine through and say that: Porto and Dynamo Kyiv advance. 

GROUP B (Arsenal, Schalke 04, Olympiacos, Montpellier)
New boys celebrate against Liverpool. 

The "irony" of this group is that the most talked of player will not even feature in it: Robin Van Persie. On paper this is a very nice draw for Arsenal to feature nicely on the top of the group, but rest assured if Arsenal fail to score RVP's name will be exhausted in football columns everywhere (and face it, if they score "in spite of" losing RVP, they will write about him regardless). Arsenal is looking to have the best defense in the EPL and should be able to keep many clean sheets against three teams with limited CL pedigrees. The recent performance of Podolski and Cazorla at Liverpool demonstrate that Arsenal might be creating a strong attacking side, which can only get better as players return from injury. 

I expect the second place to go comfortably to Schalke 04 as they get another good performance from Dutchmen Huntelaar and new-loan Afellay. 

Prediction: Quite easily Arsenal and Schalke 04. 

GROUP C (AC Milan, Zenit St. Petersburg, Anderlecht, Malaga)
Will Malaga announce themselves to the world this CL season?

AC Milan - much like Arsenal - will have journalists talking about who they sold, rather than their performances. Losing two of their star players to PSG - Ibra and Thiago Silva - the team looks to be in a bit of shambles. Their 5-1 thumping to Real Madrid in a summer friendly demonstrated how thin their defense appears without Silva and conceeding three to Juventus and one to Sampdoria demonstrated that AC Milan is potentially in a spot of trouble defensively. AC Milan never really replaced either player and with Pato constantly injured and Robinho being Robinho, AC Milan might have a tricky season. 

Malaga in 2010 joined the list of clubs who have "oil"-igarch sugar daddies. While they haven't spent as debaucherously as PSG, City or Chelsea, they have tossed some coin around. The opening of their La Liga season has looked promising and they look like they can make waves with their play. However, like PSG a lot of their purchases are aging: Saviola, Demichelis, Baptista, etc. Will this team be able to contest on multiple fronts? Time will tell. 

Zenit has demonstrated in previous seasons that they can play well as a team and aren't intimidated by bigger teams. I expect them to be the surprise performers of this group with their talented array of foreign players such as Bruno Alves, Danny, Hulk and new-boy Axel Witsel combining with the Russian stars to make a good perfomance. 

Prediction: Tough one. I am going to say AC Milan simply because of pedigree and Zenit St. Petersburg. 

GROUP D (Real Madrid, Manchester City, Borussia Dortmund, Ajax)
Jesus wept. What a group! Four league winners and some of the biggest stars of world football all in one group: this is precisely why the CL is the tournament that it is. 

Lewandowski: top striker. 
Based purely on line-ups, it is very easy to say that Real Madrid and Manchester City will run away with this group. The starting XI and benches of both teams are arguably the two best in the world. However, City fumbled in their first European attempt last year. This CL campaign City's biggest enemy will be its weak defense - City has conceded in every EPL game and the community shield. Mancini's side is very much stream-lined to be a Luftwaffe lighting-attack side, but this has left them a little short at the back. This could pose a problem as Real Madrid, Borussia Dortmund and Ajax all have lethal strikers who can pounce on any opportunity given to them. However, if City rediscovers the defensive combination of last year, they will prove to be a stiff competition to all. 

For myself, the biggest talking point will be Borussia Dortmund - a team I have absolutely fallen in love with. Combining the best players from Poland (Kuba, Pisczek, Lewandowski) with some of the key young cogs in the German machine (Reus, Goetze, Hummels), they are a master-class team. Despite having significantly less finances than Bayern Munich (last year's CL finalists, lets not forget) they dismantled them on three separate occasions last year. Their performances in the CL have been luke-warm and last year they failed to convert their domestic form abroad. However, they look as lethal as ever once again, and they will itching to upset people's predictions for this group by qualifying for the next round. With both Real Madrid and City demonstrating defensive weaknesses expect Kuba-Reus-Lewandowski to take advantage with a trademark quick combination to take advantage. 

Predictions: Real Madrid for certain. Second place? Head says: City. Heart says: Borussia Dortmund.